|
GNED 1300
First-Year Seminar |
Spring, 2003
Curtis Brown
Guidelines for Discussion Leaders
Presenters should plan on doing the following things:
1. Do the reading for that session early.
2. Communicate ahead of time with the other discussion leader for your
session to decide how to approach the class. (You might each take responsibility
for a different article, or you might take opposing sides on an issue the
readings discuss, or you might have some other approach.)
3. Take responsibility for initiating and guiding a discussion of your
topic on the Blackboard discussion board. Post an initial message asking
some questions, or raising a provocative issue, or defending a position. Then continue to prod the
discussion along. The initial message should be sent out the afternoon
of the class prior to the session at which you will present.
4. In class the day of the presentation, take approximately ten minutes
to present your "take" on the readings for that session. Guidelines
for the presentation:
-
You should take some sort of position relevant to the reading. (This might be an
interpretation, a critique, a defense against criticisms others might have, or
an interesting connection between the readings and something else -- for
instance a current issue, something else you've read, etc.)
-
You should not only take a position, but also defend it: explain what your
reasons are (why your interpretation is a good one, or why the reading is
totally wrong, or . . .).
-
However, you should not use the presentation to summarize the reading.
You should assume that we have all read the material carefully (and we
should make certain that your assumption is correct).
- After presenting your "take" on the reading, you should be
prepared to guide discussion about the readings. You should have questions to
ask and/or ideas to present. Don't be too pushy or dogmatic about this: if the
discussion goes in a direction you didn't expect, but it is still relevant to
the day's topics, that's OK. On the other hand, if the discussion gets way
off-topic or gets silly or otherwise seems to be going astray, try to bring
the focus back to the topic at hand with a new question or observation.
5. If you'd like to distribute a handout to the class, please bring
it to me no later than 10:30 on the morning of the presentation so I can
make copies for the class. (The day before would be better!)