Philosophy 2340
Symbolic Logic

Notes on Barwise and Etchemendy,
Language, Proof, and Logic, Chapter 7

Curtis Brown

(Note: symbols will not display correctly unless you have the Lucida Sans Unicode font installed.)

Conditionals and Biconditionals: and

Chapter 7 adds two new connectives to our collection of treasures: and . We can read "P Q" as "if P, then Q" and we can read "P Q" as "P if and only if Q." (Sometimes philosophers abbreviate "if and only if" to "iff.") A sentence of the form "P Q" is called a conditional. The antecedent of the conditional is P, and its consequent is Q.

As with our other connectives, we can give the semantics of the conditional and biconditional by using truth tables:

P

Q

P Q

P Q

T T T T
T F F F
F T T F
F F T T

There are a few tricky points to keep in mind in doing translations involving these connectives. Let's consider a few of the many English phrases that can be translated using conditionals. Some of the following sentences are frequently stumbling blocks for students doing translations, so if you have trouble doing the translation exercises, you might want to look over this table again!

English Sentence Translation into Symbolic Notation Comments
If P then Q
P is sufficient for Q
P Q  
P only if Q P Q note: "P only if Q" means the same thing as "if P then Q"! 
P is necessary for Q Q P Q doesn't occur without P also occurring
P if Q Q P except in the case of "only if," whatever follows the "if" is usually the antecedent of the conditional
P unless Q Q P or P Q an easy way to remember how to translate "unless" is to think of it as "if not"
P if and only if Q
P just in case Q
P Q  


Sometimes people think that "P only if Q" should be symbolized as Q P or P ↔ Q instead of as P Q. A good cure for this temptation is to think about the following example. Let W mean that I win the lottery, and let B mean that I buy a ticket. How should we translate "I will win the lottery only if I buy a ticket," that is, "W only if B"?

Clearly, it should not be translated by B → W or W ↔ B. The first means that if I buy a ticket, I will win, which is clearly not necessarily the case. The second says that I will win if and only if I buy a ticket, which implies that if I buy a ticket, I will win, and again, this isn't true. The translation we want is W → B, which says that if I win, then I bought a ticket.


Last update: February 17, 2011. 
Curtis Brown | Symbolic LogicPhilosophy Department | Trinity University
cbrown@trinity.edu