|
1
|
|
|
2
|
- Shelley’s novel was subtitled, “The Modern Prometheus”
|
|
3
|
- What happens when our power of
science and technology gains control over us?
- Due to the power of the doctors
and medicine, people no longer are allowed to die on their own terms.
- Prolonged suffering in the name
of defeating death.
- Increase in “post-mature”
deaths.
- What happens when we simply gain
too much power?
- Cloning
- Genetically-altered food
products
- Do we really want to conquer
death?
|
|
4
|
|
|
5
|
- Frankenstein and the Death Ethos
|
|
6
|
- A breakthrough in cryopreservation dubbed “A Frankenstein Experiment”
- Of mice and men?
- A research team in Hawaii dealing with mice is trying to “manage the
ever-increasing numbers
- of their mutant strains”
(Sikorski and Peters, 1998).
- Although the embryos can be frozen, the process is difficult…normal
freezing and thawing processes yield a dead result
- Keeping live rodents is costly in terms of time and budgets
- “Next, they performed an experiment a bit like Frankenstein’s: They
used micromanipulation to remove the freeze-dried sperm heads and to
inject them directly into unfertilized mouse oocytes. They idea was to see whether the
nucleus was dormant and could be revived within the cytoplasm of the
host egg…In the end, 30% of all head-injected oocytes produced viable
mouse offspring that appeared completely normal” (Sikorski and Peters,
1998).
- What does this science mean in our culture?
- Further death-denial: Not only can we be cryogenically frozen for all
eternity, but our
- reproductive capabilities
could continue indefinitely, causing death to be only a temporary
status and the continuation of our legacies
- Frankenstein serves as a warning against playing God with science and
nature. Does freezing sperm to
create never-ending offspring also, in effect, mean playing God? Will the potential offspring revolt
against the creators like the monster did against the doctor?
|
|
7
|
- Biotechnology: Good Enough for YOUR family?
- Case of Monsanto
- Genetically-engineered crops include “insect-killing,
herbicide-resistant soybeans,” a cause of controversy for the CEO Bob
Shapiro
- Monsanto is also the company who makes the drug Celebrex, which
“doesn’t appear to cause adverse gastric side effects” (Schwartz and
Borden, 1999).
- “Monsanto expects U.S. farmers to plant over 30 million acres’ worth
of its herbicide-resistant soybeans this year [1999], or roughly 40%
of the market” (Schwartz and Borden, 1999).
- “While there’s no evidence that genetically modified foods are
dangerous to eat, their environmental effects are less certain”
(Schwartz and Borden, 1999).
- Monsanto does not think that their products will cause gene crossing
into wildlife as is feared by opponents
- Is this technology, like Frankenstein’s monster, also going to lead to
a loss of control and unintended consequences? If the mutated strains of the food
are found to be harmful, the outcomes could result in “premature”
deaths. If the strains do end up
crossing into other plant species in the wild, science will have lost
control of its experiment, another nod to the Frankenstein metaphor.
|
|
8
|
- The producer of the so-called Frankenfoods and Celebrex is also a
chemical company. What does this
add to our exploration of Frankenstein in our death-denying culture?
- This company that is supposed to make life easier and better for people
with genetically-altered food products makes chemicals in Louisiana
- Louisiana is the second most polluted state in the U.S.
- Green
- A documentary illustrating the results making the life-improving products of
Monsanto and other chemical-producing plants along the Mississippi
River in Louisiana.
- The results?
- Cancer
- Environmental pollution
- Toxic waste infiltration to the surrounding neighborhoods
- Explosions and accidents
- Death
|
|
9
|
- In our death-denying culture, we categorize and isolate death. Monsanto and companies like it locate
their plants along a major U.S. river, in a predominately
African-American neighborhood.
What happens when there is an accident?
- A man, who lost a 16-year-old daughter to Non-Hodgkin’s Lymphoma,
cannot grow vegetables in his backyard anymore
- The Environmental Protection Agency will not relocate residents
- “Wish you could’ve seen Norco
before their explosion—this would be the positive side if you want to
say anything positive. Norco
looks like a refurbished town…it’s unfortunate that we lost our seven
employees—it scared the community–but the positive of that is, you
know, Norco has a new look.”
- --Lily Gallund, Shell
Community Relations, from the documentary Green
- Death, in this context, is only secondary to the “new look” of the
chemical town. Who dies, where
they die, when they die, and especially how they die are related to
socioeconomic status and race.
|
|
10
|
- Eugenics is the selection of certain people or traits that are either
desirable, and thus regenerated, or undesirable, and thus eliminated.
- Germany is very reluctant to accept or condone any kind of biotechnology
- Peter Sloterdijk, German philosopher, believes, “it is a humanistic
illusion to believe that traditional ‘nurture’ is enough when it comes
to taming the bestial dimension of man’s nature,” and he uses the terms
breeding, selection, human farms, and domestication, calling for a
“human bio-utopia,” (Laubichler 1999: 1859).
- How does this relate to Frankenstein?
- In Nazi Germany, eugenics was used to “cleanse” the population of
undesirables. Frankenstein
selected body parts from “desirable” human corpses, from their graves,
to create his monster.
- What does this tell us about our death-denying culture?
- “History, and in particular the Nazi period, then only serves to
confirm these fears [about man’s control over nature wreaking havoc]
and leads to fatalistic attitudes toward biotechnology,” (Laubichler
1999: 1859).
- Laubichler also likens this fear to the debate over stem-cell research,
which raises the question of moral rights over advances in
biotechnology. Who wins in such a
debate? If the moral right wins,
premature deaths could result. If
biotechnology wins, could the deaths be pushed back or would the
advances cause more harm than good?
|
|
11
|
|
|
12
|
|
|
13
|
|
|
14
|
|
|
15
|
|